With the ever increasing
complexity and advancement of weight machine technology, there has been a lot
talk and sometimes even arguments about which is best for training when you're
trying to lose fat and gain muscle. Is it free weights or machines? Much like
the "which came first: the chicken or egg?" dilemma there really is no right
answer, because each form of equipment is more than adequate in helping you realize
your dreams and goals for a better physique. However, I do believe that no matter
what the advances in technology are, free weights will always do a much better
job in sculpting the perfect physique than any machine. Furthermore, I doubt
the improvement of the machines that you see in the gym have really created that
much of an advantage, if any, over free weights. But, whatever your stance is
in this dilemma, the fact of the matter is that changing your life and your body
all comes down to two things; that is 1) desire and 2) commitment.
Though it can be argued that machines have advantages over free weights,
it is important to understand that first and foremost; our muscles were designed
to overcome the pull of gravity rather than overcome machine resistance. Therefore,
for those who want to make great gains in muscularity and definition, free weights
are still the way to go.
In my opinion free weights have numerous advantages over machines primarily
because of the range of motion that they give the user, which in turn makes for
a better workout. The wider range in motion makes the targeted muscles recruit
the use of other muscles that are otherwise not used when using machines. The
use of free weights also challenges the user to use proper balance and coordination
when performing the exercise thus preventing the user from cheating by using
all the available muscle fibers to perform the exercise correctly.
Unlike machines, free weights are not guided by a pulley or a cam system
that assist your body through the sticking points in the exercise. These sticking
points are the most important reps of the exercises because they are when you
are re-conditioning or reprogramming your body to adjust to the level of stress
that you are putting it under. Also, these sticking points further heighten the
respond time of your bodily systems (neural, endocrine and muscular). If observed
carefully, machines only work by keeping resistance along one constant plane
-- meaning that motion is limited and there is no need for balance because the
exercise is done the way the machine wants it done. Some might argue that the
limit in motion isolates the muscle that is being work upon. While that may be
true, if thought through carefully, every exercise that is performed on a specific
muscle actually affects another set of muscle(s) and therefore it becomes a constant
domino effect. It's been long theorized that free weights increase stabilizer
involvement, which means "working the muscles which support the acting muscles,
called prime movers", this is what I just mention in the previous statement.
For example, when you're doing a bench press, not only are you stimulating your
pectoral muscles, you're also including your shoulders as well as your triceps.
When you're working on your biceps, you're also stimulating your forearms. The
fact of the matter is that free weights involve more stimulus to the body therefore
making the body respond much better and faster. Also, free weights give much
more creativity to the user with respect to different exercises and new angles
to stimulate certain muscle groups. With the restriction in movement that some
machines have, all that really happens is less muscle development and disproportioned
muscle development in the target areas.
However, the biggest advantage that free weights have over machines is that
free weights caters to all users; tall short, bulky, skinny, long legged, short
legged, long armed, short armed, short stature, as well as to those with disabilities.
Free weights, unlike machines, are not set or design to accommodate the average
male or female frame with little flexibility to accommodate the rest of the population.
If it sounds like I'm against using machines at all, I'm not. I'm just merely
stating the upside of using free weights because a lot of people are scared to
use them. I believe machines are a good compliment to free weights if use properly.
After all, how can we better sculpt our legs without the use of the leg extensions
or the leg curls? Or to even fully stimulate the inner pectorals without the
use of pec deck or cables or to work the lats without the assistance of the lat
pulldowns? Machines are great when you're trying to burn and squeeze out that
extra rep after fatigue sets in. Machines provide increased safety for people
with injuries, and for beginners out there who wants to use strict and proper
techniques. But most of all, machines are great because they allow users to work
out in relative safety without a spotter, to total exhaustion.
So, don't be afraid to use both free weights and machine weights because
they compliment each other to help you achieve your ultimate goal. If you're
a beginner and you have no idea how to perform some of the exercises, use the
machines and observe the provided diagrams that show you how to do the exercise.
Once you get a little stronger and much more comfortable start using free weights.
The combination will provide you will the ultimate workout routine, and in time,
the ultimate body. |